Pedro Pascal is famously pretty tight-lipped about his romantic life. I mean, Pedro has no obligation to share his private life with the public no matter what, especially when he’s already given us so much. He gave daddy new meaning as Joel in The Last of Us. He practically broke TikTok with the most meme-able movie scene (alongside Nicholas Cage). The man is the friggin’ Mandalorian!

But after Pedro was recently seen out and about with Jennifer Aniston, he sparked more questions about his dating life. The 49-year-old denied any romantic attachments with Jen, saying they’re just “very good friends.” So if the relationship between Pedro and Jen is a platonic one, where does that leave us?

Pedro previously spoke to Esquire about how he’s usually pretty guarded about personal stuff. “It could have to do with the fact that I don’t have my own family and that my siblings and my chosen family are where I invest all of my emotional energy,” he says. “But I’m also a little protective of people’s experience in general.”

A lot of Pedro’s relationship history is a mystery, but we can piece together some of it based on interviews and public appearances. Here’s what we know about Pedro Pascal’s dating history.

Pedro Pascal’s Dating History

Maria Dizzia

Image Credit: Getty

Back in the 1990s, before he was famous, Pedro was in an episode of Law & Order, like every other actor in the world. He was in a season 18 episode alongside Orange Is The New Black star Maria Dizzia and, according to The Sun, that sparked a relationship between them that lasted years.

Lena Headey

One of Pedro’s most high-profile roles on his way to becoming a household name was the character Oberyn Martell in Game of Thrones. The character was mostly known for making everyone around him fall in love with him, which I imagine wasn’t much of an acting stretch for Pedro. And he may have succeeded a little too well with his co-star Lena Headey, who played Cersei.

Nothing was ever confirmed, but fans speculated that Pedro and Lena may have had a thing going when she posted a cozy Instagram with Pedro with the caption “Sunshine love” in 2014. Later that year, they were spotted together on a shopping trip in Los Angeles.

Despite that being some very couple-y activity, Pedro and Lena never said they were official. And by February 2015, Lena was pregnant with her second child, whose father is director Dan Cadan.

Robin Tunney

One more co-star Pedro was possibly linked to… sensing a pattern here? This time it’s Robin Tunney, who starred in The Mentalist. Pedro appeared on the show in 2014 and was photographed with Robin at the 2015 Emmys. Despite romantic rumors circulating about them, these two were definitely always just close friends. At the time, Robin was engaged to Nicky Marmet, and they now have two kids.

And there you have it. Most of Pedro’s romantic life remains a mystery, but perhaps some day he’ll share more with the world.